Choosing the right tenant is one of the most important decisions a landlord can make. A reliable tenant can mean consistent rental payments, a well-maintained property and fewer concerns throughout the tenancy.
With Perth's rental vacancy rate sitting at just 1.7% in September 2026, landlords may find themselves choosing between several applications. But more interest doesn't necessarily make finding the right tenant easier.
So, what should landlords consider when reviewing applications, and how can they make an informed decision?
Tenant selection involves more than reviewing an online application.
While applications provide important information, meeting prospective tenants in person creates an opportunity to understand their circumstances, answer questions and discuss whether the property suits their needs.
At D Residential Group, our Director, Diana Patrascu, takes a hands-on approach to tenant selection, regularly attending home opens alongside our property management team.
With over 20 years of industry experience, Diana understands the value of speaking directly with prospective tenants before making a recommendation to the landlord.
These conversations can provide insight into:
Of course, these conversations are only one part of the process. Every application must still be assessed fairly and consistently, with the necessary checks completed before a recommendation is made.
A strong rental application isn't necessarily the one with the highest income or longest rental history. Several factors should be considered together.
Rental History
Previous rental references can provide information about rental payments, property care and previous tenancy arrangements.
However, limited or no rental history doesn't automatically make someone unsuitable. First-time renters may still provide strong supporting information.
Employment and Income
Verifying employment and income helps establish whether the weekly rent is affordable for the household. The focus should be on an applicant's ability to meet rental payments rather than their occupation alone.
References
Speaking with previous property managers, landlords or other relevant referees helps confirm application details and provides additional context.
Suitability for the Property
Practical considerations such as the proposed number of occupants, preferred move-in date and relevant tenancy requirements can help determine whether the property is a suitable match.
No single factor should determine the outcome. Considering the application as a whole allows landlords to make a more balanced decision.
As mentioned, finding the right tenant involves more than reviewing an application. While meeting prospective tenants and considering their rental history, income and references are important, it's equally essential that each application is assessed fairly and consistently.
At D Residential Group, we bring these elements together through a structured application process.
Our process includes:
The landlord ultimately makes the final decision, supported by the information gathered throughout the application process.
Landlords have the right to select a suitable tenant, but decisions must comply with Western Australian tenancy and anti-discrimination laws.
Anti-Discrimination Laws
Under the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (WA), landlords and property managers cannot discriminate against applicants based on protected characteristics such as race, age, religion, family status or impairment.
Applications should be assessed using relevant tenancy criteria.
Rent Bidding
Under WA's rental reforms, landlords and agents cannot invite or encourage applicants to offer more than the advertised rent.
Properties must be advertised at a fixed amount, although applicants may voluntarily offer a higher rent without being prompted.
Pets in Rental Properties
Under WA tenancy laws, tenants can request permission to keep a pet, with landlords generally required to respond within 14 days.
Requests can only be refused on permitted grounds, and some refusals require an application to the Commissioner for Consumer Protection.
Protecting Personal Information
Rental applications often contain sensitive information, including identification documents, income details and references.
Property managers should collect only the information necessary for the application process and ensure it is handled securely.
Not every application will be straightforward, and sometimes additional information is needed before making a decision.
An applicant may have recently changed employment, be renting for the first time or have gaps in their rental history.
Rather than treating these circumstances as automatic concerns, it's important to consider the explanation and supporting information provided.
Where details are inconsistent or references cannot be verified, seeking clarification helps ensure decisions are based on reliable information.
Choosing a tenant without completing the necessary checks can create avoidable risks for landlords.
Rental arrears, property damage, tenancy disputes and the costs associated with finding replacement tenants can become expensive and time-consuming.
However, tenant selection isn't simply about avoiding problems. It's also about establishing a positive tenancy from the beginning.
Clear expectations, suitable tenancy arrangements and open communication can help create a better experience for everyone involved.
Taking the time to review applications carefully is an important part of protecting an investment and supporting a successful long-term tenancy.
Finding the right tenant requires experience, attention to detail and a sound understanding of WA tenancy requirements.
At D Residential Group, we take a hands-on approach to leasing, combining personal interactions at home opens with the necessary application checks to help landlords make informed decisions.
Our focus is on finding suitable tenants, maintaining clear communication and making the leasing process as straightforward as possible for everyone involved.
Looking for experienced Perth property managers to look after your investment? Get in touch with our team and Discover the Difference.